Afterpay, Klarna and Zip: Is Buy Now Pay Later Worth Adding to a Small Shop?
Short answer: Buy now pay later services can lift order values and conversion for some shops, but they cost you a merchant fee on every sale, and that fee is often higher than a standard card rate. Before you add one, work out the fee on your average order, check when the money arrives and read the refund rules. Then run a test for a set period, comparing order value and conversion rate with and without the option. Keep the test honest by changing one thing at a time, and be ready to switch it off if the numbers do not improve.
What the provider does and what you pay
With most buy now pay later services, the customer splits a purchase into several instalments, and the provider pays you the full amount upfront, minus its merchant fee. The provider then collects from the customer. You do not carry the customer's credit risk in the usual way, which is part of the appeal.
The fee is what changes the economics. Providers set their own merchant fees, and they often pair a rate on the order total with a flat charge. Those rates can differ by country, by product category and by the size of the order. Ask for a written fee schedule before you apply, because some quoted rates apply only to certain plans.
A homewares shop in Perth (Lantern and Oak, an invented name) sells a lamp for $180 and a set of linen napkins for $45. A fee of around 4 to 6 percent on the lamp is a real cost, and the same fee on the napkins takes a larger share of a smaller margin. The owner decides to offer the option only on the lamp and the bigger bundles, rather than on everything.
Check the payout timing and refunds
Ask when the money reaches your account, and get the answer in days rather than in general terms. A short settlement cycle and a batched one behave very differently in your cash flow. Check whether the payout includes the fee already, and whether it appears as one deposit or several. Your bookkeeper will need to match each deposit to the orders it covers.
Refunds need equal attention. When a customer returns an item, you must refund the sale, but the merchant fee may or may not come back. Some providers return part of the fee and some keep it. Read the terms for partial refunds, because a return of one of three items raises a different question from a full cancellation.
Also check how disputes and failed instalments are handled, and whether you need to do anything to keep the customer's account in good standing. Ask the provider how long a customer has to finish the plan after a refund, and whether the instalments stop straight away. Those details affect the customer's experience as much as the fee does. If you sell goods that are returned often, such as clothing, model the refund rate as well. A shop that sees one return in five needs a different calculation from one that rarely sees a return, and the difference can decide whether the option is worth keeping. Write the refund figure into your test notes as well.
Who it tends to suit
Buy now pay later often suits shops with higher average order values, such as furniture, clothing with multiple sizes, electronics and gifts. It can also help when customers are comparing a purchase with a competitor who offers instalments.
It usually suits a shop less well when margins are thin, when most orders are small, or when the product is cheap enough that customers would rarely need to split the cost. In those cases, the fee can eat most of the profit.
Show the option without confusing buyers
Clear labelling matters. Show the instalment amount on the product page and again at checkout, with the number of payments and the date of each. Avoid language that makes the instalments sound like a loan without explaining the terms. Australian consumer credit rules apply to some of these arrangements, and the regulators publish guidance for businesses, so check the current position before you publish any claim about a payment plan. Keep the explanation short, and link to the provider's own terms for full details.
Do not hide the price. Customers who see only a small instalment figure may feel misled when the total appears later. Show the full price first, then the instalment option.
Run a test before a long commitment
A simple test takes four to six weeks and needs only your store analytics. Divide the test into two equal periods, or split traffic if your platform supports it. In the first period, offer the option. In the second, turn it off. Compare three numbers: average order value, conversion rate and the number of refunds.
Do not judge the result on a single week. Seasonal sales, promotions and stock changes can all distort the figures. Agree in advance what result would make you keep the option, such as a rise in average order value that more than covers the extra fees, so the decision is made on evidence rather than on hope. If average order value rises but the net margin after fees falls, the option may still be a loss.
A decision checklist
- [ ] Merchant fee for your typical order calculated in writing
- [ ] Payout timing confirmed for your country
- [ ] Refund and partial refund fee treatment understood
- [ ] Dispute process and failed payment handling checked
- [ ] Price shown in full before the instalment figure
- [ ] Test period and success measures set before launch
- [ ] Clear plan for switching the option off
FAQ
Does buy now pay later always increase sales?
No. It can help with higher-priced items, but it does not always raise the total. Measure the change in order value and margin, not only the number of orders.
Should I offer more than one provider?
Only if the extra choice is clearly used by your customers. Each provider adds a fee structure, a checkout button and a reconciliation step, so start with one.
Who handles the customer's payments if they miss one?
That depends on the provider's terms. Read them carefully, and make sure your customer service team knows where to direct questions.
Designing the before and after test is the part most owners skip, and our enquiry form is a fair place to ask for help with it.