Choosing an Email Marketing Platform: Mailchimp, Klaviyo, Brevo or Another?
Short answer: Choose an email platform by three questions: how many contacts you will store, how much automation you need, and whether your sales data has to drive the emails. A shop that wants abandoned basket messages and product recommendations needs a tool that reads order data well. A service business that sends a monthly update may need only a simple editor and a clean list. Compare pricing on the number of contacts and on the number of sends, because the two can produce very different bills. Finally, check how each tool handles people who unsubscribe, since that decides what you can safely import later.
Start with your list and your sending pattern
Before you open a pricing page, write down three numbers: the contacts you have today, the contacts you expect in a year, and how many emails you plan to send each month. A list of 2,000 people who receive one newsletter a month is a very different job from 20,000 people who receive three automated messages a week.
A candle maker in Leeds, Wick and Hearth in this example, has 3,400 contacts, sends a fortnightly newsletter and runs a welcome series for new customers. The owner's goal is to avoid paying for contacts who never open anything. That goal matters more than the size of the feature list.
Compare the pricing model, not just the headline
Most platforms charge by contacts, by sends, or by a mix of both. A contact-based plan can look cheap for a large list that is rarely emailed, yet expensive for a list that is heavily emailed. A send-based plan can suit a business with a large list and infrequent campaigns. Some tools also restrict features on lower plans, such as automated flows or advanced segmentation, so the plan that fits your list may not include the automation you need.
Check the terms for contacts that are unsubscribed, bounced or inactive. Some platforms still count them towards your limit, and some remove them. That single detail can change the monthly total noticeably as your list grows. Ask each vendor to show the bill for a contact list of your size, using the same sending pattern you described, so you see the real monthly total rather than a headline price.
A decision grid for common businesses
| Business type | Main need | Look for |
|---|---|---|
| Online shop | Order data, abandoned baskets, product blocks | Native store connection and product feeds |
| Service firm | Booking reminders and occasional updates | Simple automations and clean templates |
| Newsletter writer | Frequent sends, audience growth | Good deliverability reports and sign-up forms |
| Local restaurant | Offers and events to a local list | Easy mobile templates and text-friendly editing |
The grid shows the pattern: the more your emails depend on what a customer bought or did, the more important data integration becomes. A newsletter writer can accept a simpler tool, while a shop should test how the platform reads order history before committing.
Test the features that matter with a short trial
Most platforms offer a trial or a free plan. Use it to test three things. First, import a small sample list and check that the fields arrive in the right places, such as first name, postcode and purchase date. Second, build one automated message from start to finish, including the unsubscribe link and the sender details. Third, send a test to a set of addresses you control and look at how it appears on a phone.
Do this before you move your full list. Problems with fields or sender details are easier to fix before the first real campaign goes out. A trial with a list of thirty people you know well is often enough to spot most of these problems, and inviting two colleagues to open the test emails on their own phones helps too.
Handle unsubscribes properly
UK marketing email rules sit in PECR, and the ICO's guidance is the place to check the detail. Whatever tool you choose, it must honour opt-outs quickly and keep them on record. Ask how the platform stores unsubscribed contacts. Some tools suppress them automatically across all lists, which is the behaviour you want. Others leave them in a list and rely on you to exclude them, which creates a risk of accidental sends.
Email providers also expect bulk senders to authenticate their messages and to keep complaints low. The sender guidelines published by Google are a useful reference for the basics of authentication and complaint rates, and the tool you choose should support them.
A short checklist for moving lists later
Switching platforms is common, and it goes better when you plan for it from the start.
- Export your contacts with every field, including the consent source and the date each person joined.
- Export the suppression list separately, so unsubscribed contacts stay suppressed on the new platform.
- Keep a copy of your old templates as plain files or HTML.
- Confirm that the new platform accepts the same sending domain and that the authentication records are updated.
- Send a small test campaign before switching the full list.
- Keep the old account open for a short period so late replies and bounces can be checked.
Example decision for a small shop
Suppose a bookshop has 6,000 contacts and sends two campaigns a month plus an automated welcome series and a post-purchase message. The shop should choose a platform that connects to its store, can split contacts by purchase history and charges clearly for automation. A cheaper tool with no store connection may save money on paper but cost time on manual exports each week.
FAQ
Is the cheapest platform the best value?
Not usually. A low price can hide limits on automations, reporting or support. Compare the plan you need after six months, not the plan you start on.
Should I choose a platform that my web designer uses?
It can help, because integrations are easier. However, the platform must still fit your sending pattern and your data, so test it before agreeing.
Can I keep my unsubscribed contacts when I switch?
You should keep the suppression list, not the contact details of people who opted out. Export it and import it into the new tool so they are not emailed again.
Choosing a platform goes faster with your list size and sending plan in hand, and our enquiry form is a simple way to put both together.