Lorixen.
EN

How a pull list system works for a comic shop

Short answer: A pull list system records which ongoing titles each customer wants, matches them against each week's arrivals, sets copies aside in the customer's box, and reminds people when their books are waiting. Done well, it also informs your orders, because subscriptions show demand before the order deadline. You can run it with a dedicated tool, your point-of-sale system's customer records, or a simple database, as long as it handles titles, variants, holds and reminders without manual cross-checking.

Pull lists (also called subscription boxes or pull boxes) are the backbone of many comic shops: regulars commit to titles, the shop orders accordingly, and books are set aside each week. On paper or in a spreadsheet, it works until it doesn't: a missed issue, a variant pulled for the wrong person, boxes uncollected for months. Here's how a digital pull list system works and what to look for.

The parts of a pull list

1. Customers

Each customer record holds contact details, how they want to be notified, a box number or shelf location, and any payment arrangement. If you use a point-of-sale system's customer directory, custom fields can carry the extra information. Square's help, for example, describes custom fields in its Customer Directory as a way to store business-specific information and to group and filter customers by it. A "pull box number" field or a "pull list: active" field fits that pattern.

2. Titles and subscriptions

A subscription links a customer to an ongoing title, with options:

  • Which covers: main cover only, all covers, or specific variants.
  • Quantity: usually one, sometimes more.
  • Formats: single issues, collected editions, or both.
  • Scope: main series only, or tie-ins and one-shots too.
  • Start and end: new number ones, relaunches and limited series need clear handling so subscriptions carry over or end correctly.

3. Weekly arrivals

When new stock arrives, the system matches each item against active subscriptions and produces a pull sheet: customer, box, titles, covers. Staff pull books to boxes from that sheet rather than by memory.

4. Holds and pick-up

Books in a box are effectively reserved stock. The system should show:

  • what's in each box and since when;
  • total value waiting;
  • boxes not collected for several weeks.

5. Reminders

Automatic messages keep boxes moving:

  • "Your books for this week are in" (weekly, or only when something arrives);
  • a gentle reminder after a set number of weeks;
  • a final notice before books return to the shelf, according to your policy.

6. Ordering

This is where a pull list pays for itself. Before each order deadline, the system totals subscriptions per upcoming title and variant, so you order your committed copies plus shelf stock. New series announcements can be shown to customers so they can add them before you order.

Payment options

Shops handle payment differently:

  • Pay at pick-up: simplest; risk of uncollected boxes.
  • Deposit or prepaid credit held against the account.
  • Saved card charged on arrival or monthly: convenient for customers who rarely visit or want mail delivery. If you store cards for later charges, follow your payment provider's rules. Stripe's documentation, for example, says you should add terms explaining how you'll save payment details, let customers opt in, use the saved method only for the purposes in those terms, and explicitly collect consent to charge customers when they aren't present.

Whatever you choose, state your policy on uncollected books clearly when someone signs up.

Customer self-service

A good system lets regulars manage their own lists online or in an app:

  • browse upcoming releases and add titles;
  • see what's in their box;
  • pause the list during holidays;
  • change cover preferences.

Self-service cuts phone calls and counter time, and customers add more titles when browsing is easy.

Options for running it

  • A dedicated pull list or comic shop tool: built for titles, variants and release schedules, often with release data imported. Check how it connects to your point of sale.
  • Your point of sale plus customer fields: workable for smaller shops; matching arrivals is more manual.
  • A spreadsheet or simple database: cheap, flexible, but error-prone as the list grows; fine as a starting point if structured as one row per subscription.

What to look for

  • Accurate title and variant matching, including relaunches and renumbering.
  • Pull sheets by box number, printable or on a tablet.
  • Order totals per title before deadlines.
  • Automatic reminders by email or text.
  • Uncollected-box reports.
  • Customer self-service.
  • Export of your data, so you're never locked in.

Moving from paper to a system

  1. Enter every customer once, with box number and contact preference.
  2. Enter subscriptions as one line per customer per title, including cover preferences.
  3. Run the paper list and the new system side by side for two or three weeks, comparing pull sheets.
  4. Fix mismatches (usually title names, relaunches and variants), then retire the binder.
  5. Tell customers about self-service only once the data is clean, so they don't find errors in their own lists.

A small worked example (hypothetical)

A shop in Columbus with 180 pull boxes moves from a binder to a system linked to its point of sale. On new-release day, staff print a pull sheet ordered by box number, fill boxes in under an hour, and texts go out by midday. Before the next order deadline, the owner sees eight new subscriptions to a just-announced series and orders accordingly, instead of guessing.

FAQ

How many titles make a pull list worth digitising?

Once matching arrivals by hand takes more than an hour a week, or mistakes become regular, a system saves time.

Should we charge for pull list membership?

Some shops offer discounts to subscribers instead. It depends on your margins and how many boxes go uncollected.

Can customers outside town use a pull list?

Yes, with mail delivery and saved-card payment, if you're set up for shipping.

What about variant covers and limited allocations?

State clearly that variants are subject to allocation, and record who gets priority.

If your shop's pull list lives in a binder or an overgrown spreadsheet, tell us how many boxes you run and we'll suggest a setup that fits.

Sources

WhatsAppLet’s talk