Lorixen.
EN

Email links broken or flagged? Check your click tracking

Short answer: Email click tracking works by rewriting every link in your message so it points to the sending service's redirect server first. That's how you get click reports, but it's also why links can show a strange domain, trigger "not secure" or phishing warnings, fail to open your app, or break one-time password-reset links. Use a branded tracking domain on your own domain with HTTPS, switch click tracking off for transactional mail like resets and sign-in links, and make sure one-time links survive being opened by security scanners.

Twilio SendGrid's documentation describes the mechanism plainly: click tracking rewrites all the links and URLs in your emails so they point either to SendGrid's servers or to a domain you've branded. When the recipient clicks, the tracking server records the click and redirects to the real destination. SendGrid's docs note it can track up to 1,000 links per email and offer a separate option to track links in plain-text emails too.

Other email platforms, from newsletter tools to transactional services, use the same pattern. So a link you wrote as https://yourshop.com.au/sale reaches the reader as something like https://u12345.ct.example-esp.net/ls/click?upn=....

Problems this causes

Links that look suspicious. Some readers hover or long-press a link before tapping. A long, unfamiliar domain looks like phishing, especially in emails about accounts or payments.

Spam filtering by link reputation. SendGrid's link branding documentation explains that filters and mailbox providers judge links by the reputation of the root domain, and that branding helps because you don't rely on click tracking going through a domain you don't control. A shared tracking domain carries the reputation of everyone else using it.

"Not secure" warnings. If the tracking domain serves links over plain HTTP, browsers may warn before redirecting. SendGrid's branding setup includes an option to provision an SSL certificate for the branded link domain; without one, branded links may not be served over HTTPS.

App links that open the browser instead of the app. If you link to pages that should open in your mobile app, the redirect through a tracking domain can stop the phone recognising them as app links, so customers land on the website instead.

Broken one-time links. Password resets, magic sign-in links and email confirmations are often single-use. Some corporate mail security systems open links automatically to scan them. If your link is consumed the moment it's opened, the scanner uses it up and the customer gets "this link has expired".

Broken links from rewriting. Links inside unusual markup, links with template placeholders that weren't filled in, or very long URLs can come out mangled.

Fix 1: Brand the tracking domain

Most sending services let you use a subdomain of your own, such as links.yourshop.com.au, for tracked links. Setting it up usually means adding CNAME records your provider gives you to your DNS. SendGrid's guide describes adding the CNAME records and, optionally, records for an automatically provisioned SSL certificate, so the branded links work over HTTPS.

Benefits:

  • Links show your own domain, which looks trustworthy.
  • Reputation is tied to your domain, not shared with other senders.
  • HTTPS removes browser warnings.

Check the setup by sending a test email and hovering over a link: it should start with https:// and your branded subdomain.

Fix 2: Turn tracking off where it doesn't belong

You rarely need click statistics for:

  • password resets and magic sign-in links
  • email address confirmations
  • receipts and invoices with document links
  • security alerts

Most platforms let you disable click tracking per message, per message stream, or per link (often with an attribute or setting in the template). Use a transactional stream with tracking off for these, and keep tracking for newsletters and campaigns where clicks matter.

Even without tracking, security scanners can open links. Design for it:

  • Don't perform the action on the first GET request. Show a page with a "Confirm" or "Set new password" button, and use the token only when that button is pressed.
  • Give tokens a reasonable lifetime rather than a few minutes.
  • If a link has already been used, explain what to do next, with a fresh-link button.
  • Send a test to several mail apps and devices.
  • Click every link and confirm it lands on the right page with UTM or other parameters intact.
  • Tap app links on a phone with your app installed.
  • Check that the tracking domain shows a valid certificate.

Click tracking problems often fall between teams: marketing chooses the newsletter tool, developers build the reset emails, and nobody checks how the two share settings. Write down which streams send which emails, whether each has click tracking on or off, which domain its links use, and who changes those settings. Revisit the list whenever you change provider or add a new type of automated email, such as review requests or abandoned-basket reminders.

An illustrative example

A hypothetical Perth homewares shop found customers complaining that password-reset links said "expired" on first use, and that links in sale emails looked odd. Its transactional email went through the same tracked stream as marketing, with the provider's shared tracking domain. The developer moved resets and sign-in emails to an untracked transactional stream, added a confirm button before the reset token is used, and set up a branded links. subdomain with HTTPS for campaigns. Reset complaints stopped, and campaign links now showed the shop's own domain.

FAQ

Do I need click tracking at all?

For campaigns, it's useful. For account and receipt emails, usually not.

Does click tracking hurt deliverability?

Shared tracking domains can carry other senders' reputation. A branded domain on your own domain avoids that.

Will turning off tracking affect open rates?

Open tracking is separate. Click tracking only affects links.

Why does Apple Mail show clicks I didn't expect?

Some mail apps and privacy features fetch content automatically, which can inflate engagement numbers. Treat them as indicative.

If your email links look suspicious or keep breaking for customers, send us a test email and tell us which platform sends it.

Sources

WhatsAppBook a call