Faire for makers: wholesale marketplace or direct wholesale?
Short answer: A wholesale marketplace like Faire is mainly a discovery channel: it puts your products in front of independent retailers you'd struggle to reach yourself, in exchange for commission and the marketplace's rules. Direct wholesale from your own site keeps more control and margin but needs you to find the stockists. Most small brands do best with both: the marketplace for new retailers, a direct channel for repeat stockists, and one inventory so nothing oversells.
"Is Faire worth it?" usually really means "will the commission pay for itself in new stockists?" The honest answer depends on where your brand is and how much time you have for sales. Here's a practical comparison, with Faire as the example marketplace.
A note on facts: Faire's own website blocked automated access while this was written, so the Faire details below come from its listing in the Shopify App Store, and commission and payment terms are deliberately not quoted. Read Faire's current brand terms on its own site before deciding.
What Faire is, in its own words
Faire's Shopify App Store listing describes it as an online wholesale marketplace connecting independent retailers and brands around the world. The listing says the sales channel app lets brands publish products on Faire, keep inventory levels in sync to avoid overselling, and sync orders to Shopify. It lists the app as free to install, and adds that commission and additional fees may apply to orders on Faire.
Marketplace vs direct wholesale
| Wholesale marketplace (e.g. Faire) | Direct wholesale from your site | |
|---|---|---|
| Finding retailers | The marketplace brings retailers to you | You find them: outreach, trade shows, referrals |
| Cost | Commission and fees per the marketplace's terms | Platform costs plus your own sales time |
| Payment terms for retailers | Per the marketplace's terms | Set by you |
| Minimum order | Within the marketplace's rules | Entirely yours |
| Customer relationship | Partly mediated by the marketplace | Fully yours |
| Brand presentation | Marketplace template | Your own design and story |
| Set-up effort | Low; publish from your existing catalog | Medium: wholesale pricing, login, terms |
| Best for | Getting first stockists, testing new regions | Repeat stockists, larger accounts |
Building your own wholesale channel
If you sell on Shopify, its B2B features are one way to do this. Shopify's help center says B2B is available on the Basic, Grow, Advanced and Shopify Plus plans (not Starter or Retail), with features depending on your plan, and that you can run one store for both wholesale and direct-to-consumer sales or a separate wholesale-only store. B2B customers are set up as companies, and you can tailor pricing, currency, products, payment and shipping methods for each. Other platforms have wholesale plugins or apps; check what yours offers.
A simpler start, if you have only a few stockists: a password-protected wholesale page, a PDF line sheet and invoices sent by your accounting tool.
Line sheets: the document every channel needs
Whether retailers find you on a marketplace or by email, they expect a line sheet. Keep one master version:
- Product photo on a plain background, plus one styled shot
- Product name and SKU
- Wholesale price and suggested retail price
- Case pack or minimum quantity per product
- Dimensions, materials and care
- Lead time for restocks
- Ordering terms: minimum first order, reorder minimum, payment terms, shipping
- Contact details and how to order direct
Update it each season and date it, so retailers know they're looking at the current version.
Minimums and pricing
- Set a first-order minimum that makes packing and shipping worthwhile for you, and a lower reorder minimum to encourage restocks.
- Keep wholesale prices consistent across channels where you can. Retailers notice when the same product costs them more in one place than another.
- Account for commission in your margins before listing on any marketplace, using the current rate from its own terms.
Running both without chaos
The main operational risk is stock. A retailer orders 24 candles on the marketplace while your own site sells the last ones to consumers.
- One source of inventory. Faire's listing says its app keeps inventory in sync with Shopify; if you also sell direct wholesale, make sure that channel draws on the same stock.
- Reserve wholesale stock if retail sales are unpredictable, for example by holding a set quantity aside.
- Order flow. Bring all wholesale orders, marketplace and direct, into one place for packing, so nothing is missed.
- Customer records. Note which channel each stockist came from, so you can decide later whether to invite them to order direct, within the marketplace's rules.
Verdict by brand stage
Just starting wholesale (no or few stockists): a marketplace is a sensible test. Low set-up effort, and you learn which retailers and regions respond. Watch the commission against the orders it brings.
Growing (a handful of repeat stockists): keep the marketplace for discovery, and set up a simple direct channel for stockists who reorder regularly and prefer dealing with you.
Established (many stockists, trade shows, a sales rep): direct wholesale is likely your main channel. A marketplace may still bring in new shops; judge it on new retailers gained, not total orders.
Very small batches or made-to-order: be careful with any channel that promises fast fulfilment. Make sure lead times are visible and realistic.
FAQ
Is Faire free to join?
Faire's App Store listing calls the app free to install and says commission and additional fees may apply to orders. Check Faire's current brand terms for details.
Can I sell on Faire and my own wholesale site at the same time?
Many brands do. Keep stock in one system and read the marketplace's rules on customers it introduced.
Do I need Shopify Plus for wholesale?
According to Shopify's help center, B2B features are available from the Basic plan upward, with features varying by plan.
What's the first thing to prepare?
A current line sheet with wholesale prices, minimums and lead times. Every channel will ask for it.
Weighing up wholesale channels and want stock, orders and line sheets in one tidy setup? Tell us how you sell today.