Shopify Customer Accounts: New vs Legacy and What Changes for Your Shop
Short answer: Legacy customer accounts are the older theme-based pages where shoppers sign in with an email and password. The newer customer accounts drop passwords: shoppers enter their email and receive a one-time code, and the account pages are hosted by Shopify rather than built from your theme templates. New accounts are required for Shopify's B2B features and are where Shopify is putting its development effort, but some apps that customized the old account pages need updated versions built as customer account extensions. Check your apps, theme links and customer messaging before switching.
Where the setting lives
In your Shopify admin, go to Settings, then Customer accounts. You will see whether accounts are shown in the online store and checkout, and which version is active. Shopify's customer accounts help section describes the current options. Shopify has signaled that the newer version is the long-term direction, so check that page for any announced changes to legacy accounts before you plan around them.
How sign-in differs
Legacy accounts
- Shoppers register with a name, email and password.
- Pages like login, register, account and order detail come from your theme's customer templates.
- Shoppers who forget passwords go through a reset email.
- Accounts can be optional, required, or switched off at checkout.
New accounts
- Shoppers type their email and receive a six-digit code. No password is created or stored.
- The first sign-in creates the account automatically, so there is no separate registration form.
- Sign-in can also work through Shop, which some shoppers already use.
- The account pages sit on a Shopify-hosted area that picks up your brand settings, such as logo and colors, from the checkout and accounts editor.
For a shop selling, say, coffee subscriptions, the change means fewer "I forgot my password" emails, but shoppers who are used to typing a password may be briefly confused the first time they see a code request.
What customers see after signing in
| Feature | Legacy | New |
|---|---|---|
| Order history | Theme page, list and detail | Shopify-hosted list with status and tracking |
| Reorder | Usually needs an app or theme code | Built-in option to buy again in many cases |
| Addresses | Editable in theme pages | Editable in the account area |
| Profile details | Limited | Name, email and other fields |
| Subscriptions, loyalty, wishlists | Often added by apps through theme code | Need apps that support new account extensions |
| Look and feel | Fully controlled by theme code | Branding settings plus extension blocks |
Existing customers keep their order history. The customer record in admin stays the same; only the way they sign in and view it changes.
App compatibility
This is the area that needs the most checking. Under legacy accounts, apps for loyalty points, subscriptions, wishlists, returns or referrals often inserted their features into theme templates. New customer accounts do not use those templates, so the same code cannot run there.
Apps instead use customer account UI extensions, documented on Shopify's developer site. Before switching:
- List every app that touches the account area. Look for anything with "account", "portal", "my subscriptions" or "points" in its features.
- Check each app's help docs or listing for support of new customer accounts.
- For apps that support it, find out whether you need to add their block in the checkout and accounts editor.
- For apps that do not, ask the developer about plans, or look for an alternative.
Subscription apps matter most, because customers who cannot reach their subscription to pause or skip will email you instead.
Theme links and templates
Most themes link to /account and /account/login. Shopify routes those to the right place for whichever version is active, so standard header icons usually keep working. Look out for:
- Custom links to specific legacy pages, such as
/account/register, in menus, emails or pop-ups. - Theme sections that display a "Welcome back" message using customer data. These still work on the storefront when a shopper is signed in.
- Custom code in
customers/*.liquidtemplates. This is ignored under new accounts, so any special content there needs another home.
B2B requirements
If you use Shopify's B2B features, such as company profiles, assigned price lists or payment terms, new customer accounts are required. Business buyers sign in to see their company's catalog, place orders for different locations and view company order history. A wholesale business still running legacy accounts with a separate wholesale app should plan the move together with any B2B setup.
Switch checklist
- Audit apps as described above and resolve any that do not support new accounts.
- Review theme links and remove direct links to legacy-only pages.
- Brand the account area in the checkout and accounts editor: logo, colors, and any extension blocks.
- Test with a real customer record: sign in, view an order, change an address, use reorder, manage a subscription.
- Update notification emails that mention passwords, such as the account welcome email and password reset references.
- Update help content: FAQ pages and any "How to log in" guides.
- Tell customers. A short email or banner explains the change before they meet it.
- Switch on a quiet day and watch your support inbox for the first week.
Sample customer message
"Signing in is getting simpler. From next week you will not need a password for your account. Just enter your email, and we will send you a short code to confirm it is you. Your orders and addresses stay exactly where they are."
FAQ
Do customers lose their passwords or orders when we switch?
Orders and details stay. Passwords simply stop being used, and customers sign in with a code instead.
Can we switch back to legacy accounts?
Where the legacy option is still available, the setting can be changed back. Check the settings page for current availability, because Shopify may retire it.
Will our loyalty app still work?
Only if it supports new customer account extensions. Check with the app before switching.
Are new customer accounts required for B2B?
Yes. Shopify's B2B features rely on the new version.
Before you flip the switch, our team can audit your account area, apps and theme links, so book that review here.