Lorixen.
EN

Pages stuck on page two of Google? Find and improve them

Short answer: Some of your pages probably rank just off Google's first page for searches that matter to your business. Search Console's Performance report shows them: filter or sort the queries and pages by average position, look for ones sitting roughly between 8 and 20 with a decent number of impressions, then check whether the page truly answers that search. Improving those pages, by sharpening the title, filling content gaps and linking to them from related pages, is often a better use of time than writing something new. It's a way to prioritise, not a guarantee of higher rankings.

Why these pages are worth your time

A page that already ranks around positions 11 to 20 has shown Google it's relevant to the query. It's earning impressions but few clicks, because most people don't scroll to the second page. A new article starts from nothing; an existing page in that range may need a focused improvement rather than a fresh start.

The range isn't a rule from Google. It's a practical shortlist: close enough that improvements can matter, far enough that clicks are scarce.

Understand what "average position" means

Search Console Help defines average position as the average position of the topmost result from your site. In the chart, it's averaged across your whole site; in the table, it's the average for the query, page or other dimension in that row.

Two things follow:

  • A query's average blends many searches, devices and locations, so a position of 12 doesn't mean every searcher saw you at 12.
  • Low-impression rows are noisy. Focus on queries with enough impressions over a few months to be meaningful for your site.

Finding the shortlist

In Search Console:

  1. Open the Performance report for web search.
  2. Set the date range to the last three months to smooth out weekly swings.
  3. Turn on impressions, CTR and average position.
  4. Use the Queries tab, sort or filter by position to show queries roughly between 8 and 20, and sort by impressions.
  5. Click a promising query and switch to the Pages tab to see which page ranks for it.

You can export the data to filter it more easily, but the built-in filters are enough for a first pass. Group related queries that point at the same page; one improvement can lift several of them.

Decide which ones to work on

Not every query on the list is worth chasing. Prioritise by:

  • Business value. "Emergency boiler repair Hamilton" matters more to a plumber than "how boilers work".
  • Match between query and page. If the ranking page only mentions the topic in passing, a dedicated page may be needed, but check you don't already have another page competing for the same query.
  • Intent. If the results above you are mostly comparison guides and yours is a sales page, or the reverse, think about whether your page answers what searchers want.

What to change on the page

Title and heading. Google's documentation says it uses several sources to decide a result's title link, and you can influence it by following its best practices for titles. Make sure the page title describes the page clearly and reflects how people actually phrase the search. Don't stuff every variation in.

Fill the gaps. Compare your page with what the query needs. Google's guidance on helpful content asks questions such as whether the content gives a substantial, complete description of the topic and offers original information or analysis. Add the missing answer, a clearer section, pricing information you're comfortable publishing, or local details, rather than more words for their own sake.

Make it easy to scan. Use descriptive headings, short paragraphs and a clear next step, such as a booking or quote button.

Link to it from related pages. If other pages on your site mention the topic, link to the target page with descriptive anchor text. Internal links help both visitors and search engines find your most relevant page.

Check the basics. Make sure the page is indexed, loads quickly on phones and isn't blocked or duplicated elsewhere on the site.

Measure carefully

Note the date of each change and the queries you're targeting. Rankings move for many reasons, so compare a few weeks before and after, and look at clicks and conversions as well as position. Change a handful of pages at a time rather than everything at once, so you can tell what helped.

If a page doesn't move after a fair period, look again at intent and competing pages instead of repeatedly rewriting the title.

Common mistakes

  • Chasing irrelevant queries. Ranking for something your business doesn't offer brings visits that don't convert.
  • Creating near-duplicate pages. A new page for every variation can split signals across pages that compete with each other.
  • Changing URLs. Improve the existing page; moving it resets more than it fixes.
  • Ignoring click-through. If a page reaches page one but few people click, the title and description may not match what searchers want.

An illustrative example

A kayak tour company in Nelson finds its "Abel Tasman guided kayak day trip" page averaging around position 13 for several related queries with steady impressions. The page lists the tour but says nothing about what to bring, fitness level or what happens in bad weather. The owner rewrites the title to match how people search, adds those sections with specific details, and links to the page from the blog posts about the national park. Over the next couple of months the team tracks clicks and bookings from those queries.

FAQ

How often should I check for page-two queries?

Monthly or quarterly is enough for most small businesses.

Should I focus on position 1 to 3 instead?

Those pages already get clicks. Small gains on page two can be easier to find, but both are worth monitoring.

Does this work for local businesses?

Yes. Filter by country and device, and include place names your customers use.

Is average position in Search Console the same as a rank tracker?

No. It's an average across real searches, so it will differ from a single checked position.

If you'd like help finding and improving the pages closest to page one, tell us which services matter most.

Sources

WhatsAppBook a call