Block themes and the Site Editor: is it time to switch?
Short answer: A block theme lets you edit every part of a WordPress site, including the header, footer, templates and global styles, with blocks in the Site Editor. Classic themes use PHP templates, widgets, the Menus screen and the Customizer, and they don't work with the Site Editor. Switching makes sense when you are redesigning anyway or want to change layouts without a developer; it rarely makes sense on its own if your current site works and leans on a page builder or classic-only plugins.
Plenty of Australian businesses run WordPress sites built five or more years ago on a classic theme, often with a page builder on top. They keep hearing about "full site editing" and wonder whether they are falling behind. This explainer covers what a block theme actually is, what changes for the people who edit the site, the hidden dependencies that make switching harder than it looks, and a sensible migration plan.
What a block theme is
WordPress's documentation defines a block theme as one that uses blocks for all parts of a site, including navigation menus, header, content and footer. Block themes have been part of WordPress since version 5.9.
The practical difference is where you make changes:
- In a classic theme, content is edited with blocks, but the header, footer, sidebars and archive layouts come from PHP template files. You adjust them through widgets, the Menus screen, the Customizer or theme options.
- In a block theme, those areas are templates and template parts made of blocks. You edit them in the Site Editor under Appearance → Editor.
WordPress also notes that the Site Editor is only available when a block theme is active, and that classic themes don't work with it.
What changes for whoever edits the site
Widgets become blocks. A block theme relies on blocks instead of widgets, so anything you would have placed in a widget area is placed as a block in a template.
The Customizer mostly disappears. WordPress's documentation says the Customizer isn't available in block themes unless a plugin or theme requires it. Site title, tagline and logo become blocks; colours and typography move into Styles.
Global styles replace scattered settings. Styles in the Site Editor let you set colours and font sizes for all blocks of a type, for example every Heading block, from one place. Since WordPress 6.2 you can also take the styling of one block and apply it to all blocks of the same type.
Templates become editable without code. The documentation lists working with templates, template parts and pages directly in the Site Editor, plus tools like List View, block patterns and a command palette. You can create custom templates too, for instance a different layout for landing pages.
Design changes can be exported. The Site Editor can export your theme, including templates, template parts and style settings, as a zip file. That's useful for backups or handing a design to a developer.
The hidden dependencies
Most of the difficulty in switching comes from things outside the theme:
- Page builders. If your pages are built with a page builder plugin, the content lives in that builder's format. A block theme doesn't convert it. You either keep the builder for those pages or rebuild them with blocks.
- Theme-specific features. Some classic themes bundle sliders, portfolio types or shortcodes. Switch themes and those features may vanish, leaving shortcodes printed as plain text.
- Plugins that hook into classic templates. Plugins that insert content via widget areas or classic template hooks may need a block-based alternative. Check each plugin's documentation for block theme support.
- Customizer-only settings. Anything stored only in the Customizer, such as custom CSS or header images, has to be recreated.
- Menus. Navigation moves into the Navigation block. Your old menus can usually be selected there, but check the result on mobile.
When switching makes sense
Consider it seriously if:
- you are planning a redesign anyway;
- your team regularly asks a developer for small layout changes;
- your current theme is no longer updated;
- your content is mostly made of standard blocks rather than a page builder.
Hold off if:
- the site works, converts and is rarely changed;
- most pages depend on a page builder you're happy with;
- a key plugin hasn't confirmed block theme support.
WordPress's own advice is modest: if you like building with the block editor and want full control over all parts of the site, block themes are a great fit, and it can help to try one on a test site first.
A migration plan that limits surprises
- Inventory. List templates in use (home, page, post, archive, product, 404), plugins, shortcodes, widgets and Customizer settings.
- Staging copy. Clone the site and activate the candidate block theme there, never on live.
- Rebuild the frame first. Header, footer and navigation as template parts, then global styles: colours, fonts, spacing.
- Rebuild templates. Page, single post, archive and any custom templates you need.
- Fix content. Search for shortcodes and builder content; decide page by page whether to keep the builder or rebuild.
- Check on phones. Navigation, forms and buttons on small screens.
- Export and launch. Export the theme from the Site Editor as a backup, then switch live at a quiet time and recheck key pages.
Illustrative example: a Perth physiotherapy clinic site (hypothetical) built on an unmaintained classic theme with standard blocks for content would be a good candidate. The same clinic with every page in a page builder would face a much bigger rebuild and might reasonably wait for its next redesign.
FAQ
Will switching to a block theme change my content?
Your posts and pages stay in the database. What changes is everything around them: header, footer, sidebars and layout. Shortcodes or features tied to the old theme can break.
Can I keep using my page builder with a block theme?
Often yes, but you then have two editing systems. Many owners choose one or the other to keep editing simple.
Is a block theme faster?
It depends on the theme and plugins. Removing a heavy page builder or slider can help speed; switching themes alone guarantees nothing.
Can I try the Site Editor without switching my live site?
Yes. Activate a block theme on a staging or test site and explore Appearance → Editor there.
If you're weighing a block theme against your current setup, tell us which theme and builder you use today and we'll outline what a switch would involve.